|
German philosopher, mathematician,
historian
and jurist, contemporary of Newton (1642-1727), with whom he feuded
bitterly over the invention of calculus. Although Gottfried Leibniz
left behind no philosophical magnum opus, he
is still considered to be among the giant thinkers of the 17th-century.
Leibniz believed in "pre-established harmony" between the outer world
and maind, and developed a philosophy of Rationalism by which he
attempted to reconcile the existence of matter with the existence of
God. Bertrand Russel wrote that Leibniz's intellect "was highly
abstract and logical; his greatest claim to fame is as an inventor of
the infinitesimal calculus."
…if we were able to understand
sufficiently well the order of the universe, we should find that it
surpasses all the desires of the wisest of us, and that it is
impossible to render it better than it is, not only for all in general,
but also for each one of us in particular… (in The Monadology, 1714)
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz was born in Leipzig, the son of a
professor of moral philosophy, and Catharina Schmuck, the daughter of a
famous lawyer. When Leibniz was only six years old, his father died and
he grew up in the care his mother. At school Leibniz was a brilliant
student who taught himself Latin by reading an illustrated edition of
Livy. Leibniz received his masters degree from the University of
Leipzig at the age of 18, but his academic career was cut short when
the university turned down his application for doctoral degree. After
receiving his doctorate in law at Altdorf in 1667, Leibniz entered into
the service Baron Johann Christian von Boineburg. Never looking back at
Leipzig, he moved to Frankfurt, where he threw himself into the world
of politics.
In spite of Leibniz's peculiar physical appearance was – he was
shortsighted and smallish, his nose was very obvious, his limbs were
crooked, and he had a protrusion on his head about the size of a
quail's egg – his courtly career in Frankfurt and Maiz was first marked
by success. In 1672 he traveled to Paris with his plan for a new
crudade, trying to persuade Louis XIV to expel the Turks from Egypt in
order to distract the king's attention from the possible invasion of
Holland. The ploy did not work, but for Leibniz's Paris years were
otherwise productive. Leibniz made in 1675 his most important
scientific discovery, the differential and integral calculus, but he
also found time to visit craftmen in their shops and develop an idea
for a new kind of watch, see a talking dog, and produce 150,000 sheets
of writing.
The discovery resulted in a controversy with Isaac Newton over
whether he or Newton was the inventor. Nowadays it is generally agreed
that they both discovered independently the basic foundations, Newton
first but Leibniz's publication prededed that of Newton. Leibniz's
system of notation is still in use today. Newton's absolute space also
was something Leibniz could not accept: "I hold space to be something
merely relative, as time is; . . . For space denotes, in terms of
possibility, an order to things which exist at the same time,
considered as existing together." As an alternative to Newton's physics
Leibniz published an article in the Acta Eruditorum, arguing that the movements of the planets may be explained by the existence of a cosmic fluid.
"Just what
would Newton have lost if he had acknowledged Leibniz's originality?
Absolutely nothing! He would have gained a lot. And yet, how hard it is
to acknowledge something of this sort: someone who tires it feels as
though he were confessing his own incapacity. Only people who hold you
in esteem and at the same time love you can make it easy for you to behave like this." (Ludwig Wittgenstein in Culture and Value, 1979)
While not being concerned with gaining truth and
knowledge, Leibniz had time to think about the idea of
founding a public exhibition of scientific inventions and outline
the project in Drôle de pensée (1675). After
diplomatic missions Leibniz was appointed in 1676 librarian to the Duke
of Brunswick at Hanover, a position which he retained until his death.
For his disappointment, he had to adjust to the fact that he was not
any more living in centers of fashionable scientific and philosophical
thought. One of Leibniz's duties was to prepare a history of the House
of Brunswick, a task which he found boring compared with inventing a
new kind of windmill in the Harz Mountains. In the late 1680s he
traveled to Austria and Italy, under the pretencre of collecting source
material for his work, but he was also seeking employment elsewhere,
including as the histographer of England. Eventually Leibniz was
ordered to stay in Germany until the history was complete. In 1700
Leibniz planned the Prussian Academy of Sciences in Berlin and was its
first president. Unpopular with George Luis of Hanover, Leibniz was not
permitted to go to England, when the Elector moved his court to London
as George I.
Leibniz never married. He died on Saturday, November 14, 1716, in
Hanover, embittered by ill health, plagued with gout, under secret
surveillance, neglected, and labelled as an atheist. His death was not
much noted by the academies of which he was a member. The funeral rites
were meager; Leibniz was buried in an unmarked grave. Only later it was
marked by a simple copper plate. Almost all of Leibniz's major
treatises on optics, chemistry, philosophy, economics, mathematics etc.
remained unpublished in his lifetime. Neither his two philosophical
books, the New Essays on Human Understanding (c. 1705) and Theodicy
(1710) only showed the tip of the iceberg. His work in symbolic logic
was not resurrected until the twentieth century. Leibniz's
philosophical writings, Die philosophischen Schriften, were published in 1857-90 (7 vols., edited by C.I. Gerhardt). Werke
(1864-84, 11 vols.), edited by Onno Klopp, included Leibniz's historial
and political works. Mathematical works were published in Leibnizens mathematische Schriften
(1849-63, 7 vols.). The history of the House of Brunswick was not
published until 1843. Leibniz's formalistic poems in perfect meter and
rhyme were not openly slaughtered by critics.
Leibniz was a convinced advocate of a Eurasian policy and published a collection of documents on China (Novissima Sinica,
1679). Leibniz's interest in China was prompted by the Jesuit Claudio
Grimaldi, who had spent seventeen years in Beijing and whom Leibniz met
on on journey in Italy. He saw that China was better than Europe in the
elegance of life, but Europe was ahead in abstract mathematical
sciences and metaphysics. Moreover, for his surprise he noten that
Chinese philosophy in its ancient form looks like his own philosophy.
When Father Joachim Bouvet, who had been in China, described in a
letter the I Ching, an ancient book of wisdom and oracles,
Leibniz recognized in the enigmatic hexagrams representations of his
binary digits. To demonstrate this he wrote Explication de l'arithmétique binaire (1705). "The I Ching
was important for its divinatory contents, but for Leibniz it becomes
further evidence in proving the universal value of his formal calculus
(and in a letter to Father Bouvet he suggests that its inventor was
Hermes Trismegistus; as a matter of fact, Fu-hsi, the legendary
inventor of the hexagrams, like Hermes was considered the father of all
inventions)." (Umberto Eco in Serendipities, 1999)
Along with many Germans of his age, Leibniz conducted his
correspondence mostly in Latin and French. He produced every year
hundreds of letters. To the English philosopher Thomas Hobbes he wrote
two letters (1670, 1674). Most likely Hobbes never got them; he never
replied. Between 1663 and 1672, Leibniz referred to Hobbes in his
notes, writings, and letters 98 times, mostly critically.
During his lifetime Leibniz
was a very public figure, characterized by George I of England as a
"walking encyclopedia." At that time in the small intellectual world,
Catholics and Protestants changed ideas through incessant
correspondence in mutual respect, which prepared way to the
Enlightenment. Leibniz himself tried to formulate a sound philosophical
and theological basis for church reunions projects which arose
occasionally. His hopes were high that Prostestants and Catholics would
join in a universal church.
Leibniz had a lifelong interest in alchemy, and his system, complex
and forbidding, has been seen to resemble in some ways mystical or
cabbalistic accounts of reality. Leibniz's fascination with alchemy was
inspired by Franciscus Mercurius van Helmont, a physician and
Kabbalist, who was the son of Jean-Baptiste van Helmont, the discoverer
of gas.
"Bubbles are the seed of everything," Leibniz stated in one of his
early writings. Noteworthy, the obscure idea resonates with the modern
inflationary universe model, in which our universe has been seen as a
bubble floating in an ocean of other bubbles. In his Monadologie (1714) Leibniz maintained that the divine
order of the universe is reflected in each of its parts, each part being
called a monad, a term that means 'unit' or 'unity' – or a counterpart of
atom. Monads are incorporeal automata and adre called by
Leibniz "entelechies": "There is a world of created
beings – living things, animals, entelechies and souls – in the least
part of matter. Each portion of matter may be conceived as a garden full
of plants, and as a pond full of fish. But every branch of each plant,
every member of each animal, and every drop of their liquid parts is
itself likewise a similar garden or pond." Leibniz
concluded that there must be an infinite number of substances, monads.
They are not material particles and the only way in which two monads
can differ is in having different properties. The whole range of monads
can be divided into stages from inanimate world to rational minds. This
idea he had formulated in other words in a letter to Burcher De Volder:
"Considering matters accurately, it must be said that there is nothing
in things except simple substances, and, in them, nothing but
perception and appetite. Moreover, matter and motion are not so much
substances or things as they are the phenomena of percipient beings,
the reality of which is located in the harmony of each percipient with
itself (with respect to different times) and with other percipients."
Rational monads are capable of self-consciousness, but because their
position in the universe is fixed (i.e. there is no choice of action),
there is no such thing as free will. Evil exist, but only to accentuate
goodness, one cannot be without the other. Each monad perceives all the
other monads more or less clearly, but only God perceives all monads
with utter clarity. God have pre-established a harmony between the
monads, and the world that these monads compose is the best possible.
"I must be shown that God is a person, i.e., an intelligent substance",
he concluded as an answer to Spinoza, whose God was Nature.
God is
all-powerful and morally perfect, hence, of necessity, whatever possible
world created by God is the best possible world. Whatever states of
affairs obtain in it, they do so of necessity. It has often been said, that
Leibniz's optimism was later ridiculed by Voltaire in Candide
(1759), but the real target was possibly Pierre-Louis Moreau de
Maupertuis (1698-1759), a philosopher and scientist, whose
writings attracted wide attention at that time. In Candide,
after guiding his protagonist through a number of disasters, Voltaire
showed justifiable the question that if God cannot make a better world
that the one we know, is his powers or goodness limited? However,
Leibniz intended a metaphysical concept that applied to a world of
absolutely fixed, predeterminated order. From Candide's last remark,
"We must cultivate our garden", one may conclude that Voltaire
considered work far more profitable than metaphysical speculations. -
"Whatever is, is right" (see Voltaire)
Or, as poet Alexander Pope wrote:
All nature is but art, unknown to thee;
All change, direction which thou canst not see;
All discord, harmony not understood;
All partial evil, universal good.
And, spite of pride, in erring reason spite,
One truth is clear, Whatever is, is right.
For further reading: Critical Exposition of
the Philosophy of Leibniz, by Bertrand Russell (1900); Logic and Reality in Leibniz's Metaphysics by G.H.R. Parkinson (1965); The Philosophy of Leibniz by N. Rescher (1967); Leibniz: A Collection of Critical Essays by H. Frankfurt (1972); Leibniz's Philosophy of Logic and Language by H. Ishiguro (1972); Leibniz, ed. by R.S. Woodhouse (1981); Leibnitz by S. Brown (1984); Leibniz by G.M. Ross (1984); The Philosophy of Leibnitz by B. Mates (1986); Leibniz: Language, Signs and Thought by Marcelo Dascal (1987); G.W. Leibniz's Monadology: An Edition for Students by G.W. Leibniz, Nicholas Rescher (1991); The Fold: Leibniz and the Baroque by Gilles Deleuze (1992); A Critical Exposition of the Philosophy of Leibniz: With an Appendix of Leading Passages by Bertrand Arthur Russell, John G. Slater (1993); The Cambridge Companion to Leibniz, ed. by Nicholas Jolley (1994, paperback); Leibniz and the Rational Order of Nature by Donald Rutherford (1995); Leibniz's Universal Jurisprudence by Patrick Riley (1996); Leibniz's 'New System' and Associated Contemporary Texts, ed. by Richard Francks (1997); Liebniz: Representation, Continuity, and the Spatio-Temporal by Dionysios Anapolitanos (1998); The 100 Most Influential Books Ever Written by Martin Seymour-Smith (1998); The Universal Computer: The Road from Leibniz to Turing by Martin Davis (2000); The Courtier and the Heretic: Leibniz, Spinoza, and the Fate of God in the Modern World by Matthew Stewart (2006). Leibniz's law: If one thing is identical with another the anything that is true of the one must also be true of the other. See also: eLogic Gallery: Ancient Greece to the Enlightment by David Marans (an open-access pdf ebook) & Pantheon of Logic: Insights, Images, Bios, Links From Ancient Greece to the Twenty-First Century (full text eBook) by David Marans
Selected works: - Disputatio metaphysica de principio individui, 1663
- Specimen quaestionum philosophicarum ex jure collectarum, 1664
- De conditionibus, 1665
- Dissertatio de arte combinatoria, 1666
- Dissertation on the Art of Combinations
(selections, in Philosophical Papers and Letters, translated
and edited by Leroy E. Loemker, 2nd ed., 1969) - De casibus perplexis in jure, 1666
- Nova methodus discendae docendaeque jurisprudentiae, 1667
- A New Method for Learning and Teaching Jurisprudence
(selections, in Philosophical Papers and Letters, translated
and edited by Leroy E. Loemker, 2nd ed., 1969) - Demonstrationes Catholicae, 1668-1670
- Theological Writings Related to the Catholic Demonstrations
(in Philosophical Papers and Letters, translated and edited by
Leroy E. Loemker, 2nd ed., 1969) -
Transsubstantiaatiosta (teoksessa Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz:
Filosofisia tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho ja Markku Roinila,
2011) - Specimina juris, 1669
- Confession naturae contra atheistas, 1669
-
The Confession of Nature against Atheists (in Philosophical Papers
and Letters, translated and edited by Leroy E. Loemker, 2nd ed., 1969)
- Theoria motus abstracti, 1671
- The Theory of Abstarct
Motion: Fundamental Principles (in Philosophical Papers and
Letters, translated and edited by Leroy E. Loemker, 2nd ed., 1969) - Hypothesis physica nova, 1671
- Elementa juris naturalis, 1671
- Luonnollisen oikeuden perustekijät (suom. Teivas Oksala, in niin & näin, nro 74, syksy 3/2012)
- Confessio philosophi, 1673
- De summa rerum, 1675
- De Summa Rerum: Metaphysical Papers, 1675-1676 (translated by G.H.R. Parkinson, 1992)
- Drôle de pensée, 1675
- An Odd Thought Concerning A New Sort of Exhibition (in Selections, edited by P. Wiener, 1951) - Ajatusleikki (teoksessa Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz: Filosofisia tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho ja Markku Roinila, 2011) - De vita beata, 1676 [Concerning the Blessed Life]
-
Viisaudesta (De la Sagesse, teoksessa Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz:
Filosofisia tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho ja Markku Roinila, 2011) - Cæsarini Fürstenerii de jure suprematus ac legationis principum Germaniæ, 1677
- Specimen Calculi Universalis, 1679
-
Specimen of Universal Calculus (in Philosophical Papers and
Letters, translated and edited by Leroy E. Loemker, 2nd ed., 1969) -
Universaalista kalkyylista (teoksessa Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz:
Filosofisia tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho ja Markku Roinila, 2011) - La place d'autruy, 1679(?)
-
Toisen asema (teoksessa Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz:
Filosofisia tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho ja Markku Roinila, 2011) - De progressione dyadica, 1679
- De libertate et necessitate, 1680-84 (?)
-
Vapaudesta ja välttämättömyydestä (teoksessa Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz:
Filosofisia tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho ja Markku Roinila, 2011) - Meditationes de cognitione, veritate, et ideis, 1684 (in Acta Eruditorum)
-
Meditations on Knowledge, Truth, and Ideas (in Philosophical
Papers and Letters, translated and edited Leroy E. Loemker, 2nd ed.,
1969; Philosophical Essays, tr. R. Ariew and D. Garber, 1989) -
Mietiskelyjä tiedosta, totuudesta ja ideoista (teoksessa Gottfried
Wilhelm Leibniz: Filosofisia tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho ja
Markku Roinila, 2011) - Nova methodus pro maximis et minimis, itemque tangentibus, 1684 (in Acta Eruditorum)
-
A New Method for Maxima and Minima as Well as Tangents (in Classics of
Mathematics, edited by Ronald Calinger, 1982) - Uusi
menetelmä maksimeja, minimejä ja tangentteja varten (teoksessa
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz: Filosofisia tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo
Aho ja Markku Roinila, 2011) - Non inelegans specimen
demonstrandi in abstractis, 1685-1687 [A not inelegant Specimen of
Abstract Proof / A Study in the Plus-Minus Calculus]
-
Oivallinen näyte abstractista todistuksesta (teoksessa Gottfried
Wilhelm Leibniz: Filosofisia tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho ja
Markku Roinila, 2011) - Brevis demonstratio erroris memorabilis Cartesii et aliorum circa legem naturae, 1686 (in Acta Eruditorum)
-
A Brief Demonstration of a Notable Error of Descartes and Others
Concerning a Nature Law (in Philosophical Papers and Letters,
translated and edited by Leroy E. Loemker, 2nd ed., 1969) - Lyhyt
todistus Descartesin ja muiden huomattavasta virheestä (teoksessa
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz: Filosofisia tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo
Aho ja Markku Roinila, 2011) - Des méthodes de réunion, 1687
-
Methods of Reunion (in The Art of Controversies, edited and translated
by Marcelo Dascal, Quintin Racionero & Adelino Cardoso, 2006) -
Kirkkojen yhdistymisestä (teoksessa Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz:
Filosofisia tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho ja Markku Roinila, 2011) - De arte characteristica ad perficiendas scientias ratione nitentes, 1688
- Karakteristiikan
taidosta tieteiden täydellistämiseksi (teoksessa Gottfried Wilhelm
Leibniz: Filosofisia tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho ja Markku
Roinila, 2011) - Fundamenta calculi ratiocinatoris, 1688 [Fundamentals of the calculus of reasoning]
-
Päättelykalkyylin perusteet (teoksessa Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz:
Filosofisia tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho ja Markku Roinila, 2011) - Specimen calculi logici, 1690
-
A Study in the Logical Calculus (in Philosophical Papers and
Letters, translated and edited by Leroy E. Loemker, 2nd ed., 1969) -
Loogisesta kalkyylista (teoksessa Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz:
Filosofisia tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho ja Markku Roinila, 2011) - Von der wahren Theologia mystica, 1690 (?)
-
On the True Mystical Theology (in Philosophical Papers and
Letters, translated and edited by Leroy E. Loemker, 2nd ed.,
1969) - Todellinen Theologia mystica (teoksessa
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz: Filosofisia tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho ja
Markku Roinila, 2011) - Memoire pour des Personnes éclairées et de bonne intention, 1692
-
Muistio hyvää tarkoittaville ja valistuneille
henkilöille (teoksessa Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz: Filosofisia
tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho ja Markku Roinila, 2011) - Codex juris gentium diplomaticus, 1693
- La Felicité, 1694-1698 (?)
- Happiness (in The Shorter Leibniz Texts, edited and translated by Lloyd Strickland, 2006) -
Onnellisuus (teoksessa Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz: Filosofisia
tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho ja Markku Roinila, 2011) - Von der Weisheit, 1694-1698 (?)
-
On Wisdom (in Philosophical Papers and Letters, translated
and edited by Leroy E. Loemker, 2nd ed., 1969) -
Onnellisuuden tiede (teoksessa Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz:
Filosofisia tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho ja Markku Roinila,
2011) - Specimen dynamicum, 1695 (in Acta Eruditorium)
- A Specimen of Dynamics (in Philosophical Essays, translated and edited by Roger Ariew, 1989) -
Tutkimus dynamiikasta (teoksessa Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz:
Filosofisia tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho ja Markku Roinila,
2011) - Système nouveau de la nature et de la
communication des substances, aussi bien que de l'union qu'il y a entre
l'âmem et le corps, 1695 (in Journal de sçavans)
- New System of
the Nature of Substances and their Communication (in The Shorter
Leibniz Texts. A Collection of New Translations, edited and translated
by Lloyd Strickland, 2006) - Substanssien luontoa ja
kanssakäymistä sekä ruumiin ja sielun unionia koskeva uusi
järjestelmä (teoksessa Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz: Filosofisia
tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho ja Markku Roinila, 2011) - Troisième éclaircissement: Extrait d'une lettre de M. Leibniz, 1696 (in (Journal des Savants)
- Extract
from a Letter Written by M. Leibniz about his Philosophical. Hypothesis
(1696) ('Third Explanation of the New System') (in Philosophical Texts,
edited and translated by Richard Francks and R.S. Woolhouse, 1998)
- Ote herra Leibnizin kirjeestä (teoksessa
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz: Filosofisia tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho
ja Markku Roinila, 2011) - Tentamen anagogicum, ca. 1696 (published in 1890)
-
Tentamen Anagogocum: An Anagogical Essay in the Investigation of
Causes (in Philosophical Papers and Letters, translated and
edited by Leroy E. Loemker, 2nd ed., 1969) - Tentamen
anagogicum: Anagoginen tutkielma syiden analyysista (teoksessa
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz: Filosofisia tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho ja
Markku Roinila, 2011) - De rerum originatione radicali, 1697 (1840, edited by Johann Eduard Erdmann)
-
On the Ultimate Origination of Things (in The Shorter Leibniz Texts. A
Collection of New Translations, edited and translated by Lloyd
Strickland, 2006) - Kaikkeuden perimmäisestä alkuperästä (teoksessa
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz: Filosofisia tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho
ja Markku Roinila, 2011) -
Novissima Sinica, 1697/1699
- Writings on China (edited by Daniel J. Cook and Henry Rosemont Jr., 1994) - Unvorgreiffliche Gedanken, betreffend die Ausübung und Verbesserung der Teutschen Sprache, 1697
- De
ipsa natura sive de vi insita actionibusque creaturarum, pro dynamicis
suis confirmandis illustrandisque, 1698 (in Acta Eruditorum)
-
Nature Itself, or, The Inherent Force and Activity of Created Things
(in Philosophical Texts, edited by R.S. Woolhouse and Richard Franks,
1998) - Luonnosta itsestään (teoksessa Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz:
Filosofisia tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho ja Markku Roinila, 2011) - Godefridi Guilielmi Leibnitii Accessiones Historicae: Chronicon Coenobii Montis-Francorum Goslariae... 1698, 1700
- Lettre touchant ce qui est indépendant des Sens et de la Matière, 1702
- De dyadicis, 1702
-
Kaksittaisluvuista (teoksessa Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz:
Filosofisia tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho ja Markku Roinila,
2011) - Méditation sur la notion commune de la justice, 1702-1703 (?)
-
Reflections on the Common Concept of Justice (in Philosophical
Papers and Letters, translated and edited Leroy E. Loemker, 2nd ed.,
1969) - Mietteitä oikeuden yleiskäsitteestä
(teoksessa Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz: Filosofisia tutkielmia,
toim. Tuomo Aho ja Markku Roinila, 2011) - Nouveaux essais sur l'entendement humain, 1704 (published in 1765)
- New Essays Concerning Human Understanding (translated by Alfred Gideon Langley, 1896) / New Essays on Human Understanding (edited by Peter Remnant and Jonathan Bennett, 1981) -
Uusia tutkielmia inhimillisestä ymmärryksestä: esipuhe (teoksessa
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz: Filosofisia tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho ja
Markku Roinila, 2011) - Essais de
Theodicée, 1710 (appendices: Reflexions sur l'ouvrage que M. Hobbes a
publié en Anglois, de la Liberté, de la Necessité et du Hazard &
Remarques sur le Livre de l'origine du mal, publié depuis peu en
Angleterre)
- Theodicy. Essays on the Goodness of God, the Freedom
of Man and the Origin of Evil (edited by Austin Ferrer, translated by
E.M. Huggard, 1985) - Tutkielmia teodikesta: kolmas osa, §
405-417 & Huomautuksia teokseen, jonka herra Hobbes on
englanniksi julkaissut vapaudesta, välttämättömyydestä ja sattumasta
(teoksessa Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz: Filosofisia tutkielmia,
toim. Tuomo Aho ja Markku Roinila, 2011) - Principles de la Nature et de la Grace, fondés en raison, 1714
- The Principles of Nature and of Grace, Based on Reason (in Leibniz Selections, edited by Philip P. Wiener, 1951) -
Monadologia (suom. Jyrki Siukonen, 1995) / Luonnon ja armon
järkiperäiset periaatteet (teoksessa Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz:
Filosofisia tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho ja Markku Roinila, 2011)
- A Collection of Papers, which passed between the Late
Learned Mr. Leibnitz and Dr. Clarke in the Years 1715 and 1716:
Relating to the Principles of Natural Philosophy and Religion, 1717.
- Otium hanoveranum, sive, Miscellanea, 1718
- Monadologie, 1720 (translated into German by Heinrich Köhler)
-
The Monadology and Other Philosophical Writings (translated by Robert
Latta, 1898) / The Monadology of Leibniz (with an introduction,
commentary & Supplementary Essays by Herbert Wildon Carr, 1930) /
Monadology: An Edition for Students (edited by Nicholas Rescher, 1991) -
Monadologia (suom. Jyrki Siukonen, 1995) / Monadologia (teoksessa
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz: Filosofisia tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho
ja Markku Roinila, 2011) - Des Freyherrn von Leibnitz kleinere philosophische Schriften, 1740
- Svmmi polyhistoris Godefridi Gvilielmi Leibnitii Protogaea..., 1749
- Opera Omnia, 1768
- Discours de métaphysique, 1846 (edited by C.L. Grotefend)
- Discourse on Metaphysics (in Discourse on Metaphysics and Other Essays, translated by Daniel Garber and Roger Ariew, 1991) -
Metafysiikan esitys (teoksessa Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz: Filosofisia
tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho ja Markku Roinila, 2011) - Leibnizens mathematische Schriften, 1849-63 (7 vols., edited by C.I. Gerhardt)
- Die Philosophischen Schriften, 1857-90 (7 vols., edited by C.I. Gerhardt)
-
Kirjeenvaihto Samuel Clarken kanssa (PS, VIII, s. 352-440; teoksessa
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz: Filosofisia tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo
Aho ja Markku Roinila, 2011)
- Briefwechsel zwischen Leibniz und Christian Wolff, 1860 (edited by C.I. Gerhardt)
- Rechtsphilosophisches aus Leibnizens Ungedruckten Schriften, 1885 (edited by Georg Mollat)
- The Philosophical Works of Leibnitz ..., 1890 (with notes by George Martin Duncan)
- Opuscules et fragments inédits de Leibniz, 1903 (edited by C.I. Gerhardt)
- Sämtliche Schriften und Briefe, 1923- (Reihe I-VIII, ed. Deutsche Akademie der Wissenschaften)
-
Kirjeenvaihtoa Antoine Arnauld'n kanssa (SSB, II; teoksessa Gottfried
Wilhelm Leibniz: Filosofisia tutkielmia, toim. Tuomo Aho ja Markku
Roinila, 2011) - Philosophical Writings of Leibniz, 1934 (selected and translated by Mary Morris)
- Selections, 1951 (edited by Philip P. Wiener)
- Theodicy,
Essays on the Goodness of God, the Freedom of Man, and the Origin of
Evil, 1952 (edited with an introd. by Austin Farrer; translated by E.M.
Huggard)
- Philosophical Papers and Letters, 1956 (2 vols., edited by Leroy E. Loemker, 2nd ed., 1969)
- The Leibniz-Clarke Correspondence, 1956 (edited by H.G. Alexander)
- Logical Papers, 1966 (translated and edited by G.H.R. Parkinson)
- Philosophical Papers and Letters, 1969 (edited by Leroy E. Loemker)
- Die Werke von Leibnitz, 1970 (11 vols., edited by O. Klopp)
- Political Writings, 1972 (edited by Patric Riley)
- New Essays on Human Understanding, 1981 (translated and edited by Peter Remnant and Jonathan Bennett)
- Textes inédits de G.W. Leibniz, 1985 (2 vols., edited by Gaston Grua)
- Discourse on Metaåhysics and Related Writings, 1988 (trans. and eds. R.N.D. Martin and S. Brown)
- Opera Omnia, 1989 (6 vols.)
- Philosophical Essays, 1989 (edited by Roger Ariel and Daniel Garber)
- Writings on China, 1994 (edited by Daniel J. Cook and Henry Rosemont Jr.)
- Philosophical Texts, 1998 (edited by R.S. Woolhouse and Richard Franks)
- The
Labyrinth of Continuum: Writings on the Continuum Problem, 1672-1686,
2001 (edited and translated by Richard T.W. Arthur)
- G.W. Leibniz and Samuel Clarke: Correspondence, 2004 (edited by Roger Ariew)
- The Art of Controversies, 2006 (edited and translated by Marcelo Dascal, Quintin Racionero & Adelino Cardoso)
- The Shorter Leibniz Texts. A Collection of New Translations, 2006 (edited and translated Lloyd Strickland)
Some rights reserved Petri Liukkonen (author) & Ari Pesonen. Kuusankosken kaupunginkirjasto 2008
|