In Association with Amazon.com

Choose another writer in this calendar:

by name:
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

by birthday from the calendar.

Credits and feedback

TimeSearch
for Books and Writers
by Bamber Gascoigne


Averroes (1126-1198)

 

Medieval Spanish-Arab philosopher, physician, and jurist of the Shariah law, who reintroduced Aristotelian thought to Western Europe. After Latin versions of Averroes' commentaries on Aristotle started to circulate among scholars, the works of the great Greek philosopher were rediscovered. Averroes tried to unite Aristotle with religious thinking. He argued that the teachings of Aristotle are not in conflict with the Holy Law. "He gave to Aristotle the sort of reverence that is given to the founder of a religion," said Bertand Russell in A History of Western Philosophy (1946). In the West Averroes was a very important thinker, but in the Islamic world his rationalist theology had little influence until the nineteenth century. 

"For it is evident from more than one verse in the Book of God Almighty that He calls upon men to believe in the existence of the Originator, glory be to Him, through rational arguments detailed specifically therein, such as the saying of the Almighty: "O people, worship your Lord who has created you as well as those who came before you"; and as the other saying of the Almighty: "Is there any doubt about Allah, Maker of the heavens and the earth?" in addition to many other verses in the same vein." (in Faith And Reason In Islam by Averroes, translated by Ibrahim Najjar, Oneworld Publications Ltd, 2001)

Abu al-Walid ibn Ahmad ibn Rushd, know in Europe as Averroes, was born in Córdova, the capital of Muslim Spain, where he spent the most of his life. He was a scion of a long line of religious judges and statesmen in Andalusia. Following the traditions of his family, Averroes was educated in Islamic law, but also in Hellenistic sciences in their Arab form. Later he served as the religious judge (qadi) of Seville (1169-1172), and chief judge of Córdova (1172-1182).

The turning point in Averroes' career came in 1169. His friend Ibn Tufayl, a physician and the author of the philosophical allegory Hayy Ibn Yaqzan, introduced him to the calip Abu Ya'qub Yusuf, who was genuinely interested in philosophy. According to the historian al-Marakushi, the caliph asked Averroes, "What do the philosophers believe regarding heaven? Is it eternal or created in time?" Averroes feigned ignorance of philosophy, but Ibn Tafayl recommended Averroes' talents as the Commentator of Aristotle. Thus he was invited to write his famous comments on the texts of the philosopher in their Arabic translations. He often produced short, medium, and long commentaries on the same work. The short commentaries he frequently peppered with insights into contemporary issues.

"How wonderful is this man and how different is his nature from human natures generally," Averroes wrote on Aristotle in Kitab al-Qiyas. "It is as though divine art brought him forth so as to inform us, humans, that ultimate perfection is possible in the human species perceptibly and demonstrably." However, it is probable that he was not acquainted with Greek and based his views on Syriac and Arabic translations.

In 1182 Averroes succeeded Ibn Tufayl as royal physician to caliph at the court of Marrakesh. The caliph died a few years later. When his son Abu Yusuf Ya'qub, nicknamed al-Mansur, succeeded his father, Averroes continued to enjoy the royal patronage until 1195 when he was tried as a heretic by the religious community of Córdova. According to some sources, Averroes had referred al-Mansur in the Book of Animals as the "king of the Berbers" (al-barbar), which could be read as Barbarians. Averroes was banished in disgrace and many of his works were burned. After a period of exile, he was restored to grace and the edicts against him were rescinded. Averroes died in 1198 in Marrakesh, Morocco. With his death, Muslim philosophy in Spain ended.

Even during his lifetime Averroes' philosophy was considered controversial, but he had a great impact on Western-European thought. Also his compendium of medicine, al-Kulliyat (in Latin, Colliget) was used for centuries. In Islamic lands, where orthodoxy and al-Ghazali's intuitive and mystical sense of the Divine won, Averroes' rationalism did not have following and he has remained a marginal figure. Farah Antun's translation of Ernest Rénan's (1823-1892) historical essay Averroès et l'Averroïsme (1866, rev. ed., 1882) revived interest in him; Averroes was seen as the harbinger of an attempt to modernize Islam. In his study of the life and philosophy of Averroes, Antun represented him as a victim of religious persecution.  

During the Middle Ages, Islamic scholars preserved ancient Greco-Roman learning. At the same time Western scholars had almost completely forgotten Aristotle and the great cultural legacy of the Greeks. In Islamic Spain there were numerous important libraries, and Christian scholars travelled south to make use of these resources. Greek texts had been translated into Arabic already after the Arab armies marched into Syria and Iraq. Severus Sebokht, who died in 667, wrote commentaries on the Rhetorica of Aristotle in the Monophysite monastery of Qinnesrin in northern Syria. Also Athanasius of Balad (d. 696) and George, Bishop of the Arabs (d. 724) produced commentaries and translations. Alexandria, the most important center for the study of Greek philosophy in the seventh century, fell in 641. Spain was invaded and overwhelmed by Muslim army in 710-712. With its palaces, mosques and libraries, Córdova became the most brilliant city in Europe.

After Greek and Arabic texts began to be translated in great numbers, the writings of the great Arabic philosophers, mostly importantly Avicenna (Ibn Sina, 980-1037) and Averroes, became available. They also offered quite unfamiliar ideas. When Averroes' works started to spread after 1230, they were received with much enthusiasm and curiosity. Pope Gregory IX ordered a commission to examine what measures could be taken to permit Christians to study books that were not allowed to be taught. However, in the 1270s Siger of Brabant, Boethius of Dacia, and Bernier of Nivelles were condemned for Averroistic heresies at Paris. Dante was accused of Averroism shortly after he died and his book, De Monarchia, was burned by the order of Pope John XXII.

From the thirteenth to mid-seventeenth centuries scholars regularly read Aristotle with Averroes' commentaries. In Raphael's celebrated fresco The School of Athens (1510-11) in the Stanza della Segnatura in the Vatican, the figure of Averroes is found standing behind Pythagoras and looking over his shoulder. And much later, Averroes' life inspired the Egyptian film director Youssef Chahine's film Destiny (1997), which warned of the dangers of fundamentalism. The Argentinian writer Jorge Luis Borges portaryed the scholar in 'Averroës' Search' (The Aleph, 1949) at work in his library, trying solve the enigma of the words "tragedy" and "comedy". Eventually he writes that tragedy means "panegyric," and that comedy means "satire." Too loyal to Islam, he cannot break circle of his own culture.

One of Borges's sources was the French critic and historian Ernest Rénan, who argued in Averroès et l'Averroïsme (1852) that Averroes' paraphrase of the Poetics of Aristotle evinces ignorance of Greek Literature. Borges takes up the view: "Averroës's blunders in matters of Greek literature cannot but make one smile. He imagines that tragedy is nothing more than the art of encomium, comedy the art of censure; he then claims to find tragedies and comedies in the Arabic panegyrics and satires, and even in the Koran!" Borges's story is a postmodern fiction-about-fiction. At the end Averroes vanishes, to give room to the voice of the author, who explains that he tried to narrate the process of failure, but on the last page he felt that "Averroës, trying to imagine what a play is without ever having suspected what a theater is, was no more absurd than I, trying to imagine Averröes yet with no more material than a few snatches from Renan, Lane, and Asín Palacios."

Averroes' works include medical and astronomical writings, commentaries, and judicial and conceptual defenses of philosophy. As a physician he argued that the most important aspects of preserving health are a good digestion and a sound bowel-movement. Fruits and herbs should be avoided. Averroes became an authority among both Jews and Christians, and his commentaries on Aristotle influenced such theologians as Rabbi Moses ibn Maimon (1135-1204), St. Thomas Aquinas, who quoted him five hundred and three times, and Albert the Great. Ibn Maimon declared himself to be a disciple of a pupil of Ibn Bajja. Averroes' commentaried he began to read in exile in Egypt.

Averroes opposed the Ash'arite theologians, led by the great Muslim thinker Abu Hamid al-Ghazali (1058-1111), whose onslaught on Greek-Arabic philosophy is said to have signaled the death of philosophy in the East. Al-Ghazali believed that it is impossible to proof the existence of God rationally. As an answer to al-Ghazali's Tahafut al-Falasifah (Incoherence of the Philosophers) Averroes wrote Tahafut al-Tahafur (Incoherence of the Incoherence). He also criticized in it Ibn Sina's Neoplatonic metaphysics. In Exposition of the Method of Proof Averroes dealt with the question of God's existence and proposed his own proofs. The treatise was not translated into Latin but St. Thomas Aquinas' (1225-1274) famous approach to the question in The Summa Theologica rely upon Aristotle in similar way.

"Every prophet is a philosopher, but not every philosopher is a prophet", Averroes thought. Not everybody was capable of interpreting Qur'anic texts – only the adept or "people of demonstration" are able to undertake the interpretation of ambiguous passages in the Qur'an. But there are certain doctrines about God, which must be accepted in toto, such as the existence of God as Creator and Sustainer of the world, the creation of the world by God, the validity of prophecy, and the resurrection of the body on the Last Day.

Averroes did not see any real conflict between philosophy and religion, or philosophical texts (Aristotle) and religious texts (Qur'an), "philosophy has always existed among the adepts of revelation, i.e. the prophets, peace be on them." Truth may be discovered by philosophers through logic, but it may also be reveled figuratively, as it is in scriptures. "All that is wanted in an enquiry into philosophical reasoning has already been perfectly examined by the Ancients. All that is required of us is that we should go back to their books and see what they have said in this connection. If all that they say be true, we should accept it and if there be something wrong, we should be warned by it. " (On the Harmony of Religions and Philosophy, in Arabic Kitab fasl al-maqal, see: Medieval Sourcebook )

In the West, Averroes' support to the idea that there are different paths to the truth, was misunderstood. His attempt to harmonize religion and philosophy led to accusations of accepting the doctrine of "double truth," that a thing can be true in philosophy or according to reason while its opposite is true in theology or according to faith. The strict Averroist Pietro Pomponazzi (1462-1525) went even further and argued, that Averroes proved that religious laws are neither true nor false, but designed to lead people to salvation and happiness (Averroes and his Philosophy by Oliver Leaman, 1997, p. 171).

Diverging from many Islamic thinkers, Averroes showed little ethusiasm for mysticism. He believed that the intellect is universal and immortal. The relationship between the Active Intellect and the material intellect is what form is to matter; the Active Intellect is a "power of in the soul" and common to all mankind and eternal. According to Averroes, all generable and corruptible entities are made up of matter and form; soul is the the form or first perfection of a natural body. For these thoughts he was condemned for not believing in the immortality of the individual soul. In popular myth he was regarded as an atheist refuted by St. Thomas Aquinas.

For further reading: Averroès et l'Averroïsme by E. Rénan (1852); Philosophie und Theologie von Averroes by M.J. Müller (1875); Metaphysik des Averroes by M. Horten (1912); Die durch Averroes erhaltene Fragmente Alexanders zur Metaphysic des Aristoteles by J. Freudenthal and S. Fränkel (1884); Ma ba'd al-Tabi'a, ed. M. al-Qabbani (1303/1885); Epitome der Metaphysik, by S. van der Bergh (1924); Ibn Rochd (Averroes) by L. Gauthier (1948); Averroës on the Harmony of Religion and Philosophy by George F. Hourami (1961); Ibn Rushd wa Falsafuh by Farah Antun (1988, orig. publ. 1903); Ibn Rushd (Averroes) by Dominique Urvoy (1991); Alfarabi, Avicenna, and Averroes, on Intellect: Their Cosmologies, Theories of the Active Intellect, and Theories of Human Intellect by Herbert Alan Davidson (1992); Averroes, Aquinas, and the Rediscovery of Aristotle in Western Europe by Majid Fakhry (1997); Averroes and the Enlightenment, ed. by by Murad Wahbah (1996); Averroes and his Philosophy by Oliver Leaman (1997); Averroes: His Life, Works and Influence by Majid Fakhry (2001) 

Editions:

  • In Meteorologica Aristotelis, 1488 (published in Venice by Andreas Torresanus, Latin translation of Talkhis al-Athar al-'ulwiyah, 1-3)
  • Abhumeron Abynzoar. Colliget Auerrois, 1497 (Venetiis, ed. Hieronymus Surianus, transl. Jacobo Hebreo, translation of Taysir fi al-mudawah wa-al-tadbir)
  • Quaestio Auerrois in librum priorum, 1497 (published in Venice by Aldus Manutius, Latin translation of Talkhis kitab al-Qiyas)
  • Opera omnia Aristotelis Stagiritae…cum Averrois Cordubensis in ea opera Commentariis, MDLX  (11 vols.)
  • Collectaneorvm de re medica Auerrhoi philosophi, 1537 (Lugduni: apud Seb. Gryphium)
  • Colliget Averrois: totam medicinam ingentibus voluminibus ab alijs traditam mira quadam breuitate [et] ordine sic ad amusim complectens, 1542 (Venetiis, Latin translation of Kitab al-Kulliyat)
  • In Moralia Nicomachea Expositione, 1562
  • Aristotelis Stagiritae Metaphysicorum libri XIIII cum Averrois Cordubensis in eosdem commentariis..., 1562 (Venetiis, by Junta)
  • Aristotelis opera cum Averrois commentariis, 1562 (Venetiis, 9 vols.)
  • Bidayat al-Mujtahid wa nihyat al-Muqtasid, 1353/1953 (2 vols.)
  • Averrois Cordubensis Commentarium Magnum in Aristotelis De Anima Libros, 1953 (ed. F.S. Crawford)
  • Averroes' Tahafut al-Tahafut (The Incoherence of the Incoherence), 1954 (tr. S. Van den Bergh)
  • Incoherence of the Incoherence, 1955 (edited by Simon Van Den Bergh)
  • Commentary on Plato's "Republic", 1956 (edited by E. I. J. Rosenthal, repr. 1966)
  • On Aristotle's De Generatione et Corruptione, 1958 (edited by Samuel Kurland)
  • Katab fasl al-maqal, 1959 (ed. G. F. Hourani)
  • Averroes On the Harmony of Religion and Philosophy, 1961 (edited by G. F. Hourani)
  • Opera Aristotlis cum Averrois Cordubensis Commentaaris, 1962 (based on the 1562-74 Venice edition)
  • Talkhis al-Khataba, 1969 (ed. M.S. Salim)
  • Manahij al-adilla fi 'aqa'id al-Milla, 1969 (edited by M. Qasim)
  • Talkhis Kitab Aristutalis fi-l-Shi'r, 1971 (edited by M.S. Salim) - Averroes' Middle Commentary on Aristotle's Poetics, 1986 (translated by C.E. Butterworth)
  • Averroes' Three Short Commentaries on Aristotle's Topics, Rhetoric and Poetics, 1977 (edited and translated by C.E. Butterworth)
  • Kitab al-Sama' al-tabi'i: al-jawami' fi al-falsafah, 1983 (edited by J. Puig)
  • Averroes' Middle Commentaries on Aristotle's Categories and De Interpretatione, 1983 (translated by C.E. Butterworth)
  • Commentaria Averrois in Galenum, 1984 (translated by M.C. Vazquez de Benito)
  • Ibn Rushd's Metaphysics, 1984 (translated by C. Genequand)
  • Ibn Rushd: Grand Commentaire et Paraphrases des 'Seconds Analytiques' d'Aristote, 1984 (ed. A. Badawi)  
  • Averroes on de Substantia Orbis, 1986 (edited by A. Hyman)
  • Rasa'il Ibn Rushd al-Tibbiyya,  1987 (edited by G. Anawati and S. Zayid)
  • Kitab al-Kulliryyat fi'l-Tibb, 1987 (2 vols., edited by J.M. Fórneas Besteiro and C. Álvarez de Morales)
  • Rasâ'il Ibn Rushd al-tibbiyya, 1987 (edited by G.C. Anawati and S. Zayed) - Medical Manuscripts of Averroes at El Escorial, 1986 (translated by G.C. Anawati and P. Ghalioungui)
  • Sharh al-Sama' wa'l-'Alam, 1994 (edited by G. Endress)
  • Averrois Commentaria Magna in Aristotelem. De Celo et Mundo, 2003 (2 vols.)


In Association with Amazon.com


Some rights reserved Petri Liukkonen (author) & Ari Pesonen. Kuusankosken kaupunginkirjasto 2008


Creative Commons License
Authors' Calendar jonka tekijä on Petri Liukkonen on lisensoitu Creative Commons Nimeä-Epäkaupallinen-Ei muutettuja teoksia 1.0 Suomi (Finland) lisenssillä.
May be used for non-commercial purposes. The author must be mentioned. The text may not be altered in any way (e.g. by translation). Click on the logo above for information.